Personal Injury vs. Workers’ Comp: Which One Applies to Your Work-Related Injury?

From those who comb through paperwork in the office to those operating machinery at the construction site, South Carolina workers are no strangers to on-the-job injuries. 

While most employees can recover compensation through their workers’ compensation benefits, there is another avenue of recovery: a personal injury claim. 

How do you know if your work-related injury falls under workers’ compensation or a personal injury claim? Is it possible to file both? 

Keep reading to find out what our lawyers at Hoffman Law Firm have to say, and how we can help in the event of an injury! 

Defining Workers’ Comp and Personal Injury


The first step to understanding which claim to file and how to begin seeking compensation starts with understanding workers’ compensation and personal injury claims. 

What is a Workers’ Compensation Claim? 

Worker’s compensation is a form of insurance, or protection, provided by your employer that provides monetary benefits and medical care for workers who become injured or ill as a result of their workplace duties. 

In South Carolina, benefits available through workers’ compensation coverage include: 

  • Medical treatment costs 
  • Wage replacement for lost income 
  • Permanent disability benefits 
  • Death benefits for dependents 

What is a Personal Injury Claim? 

A personal injury claim is a legal request where an individual can seek compensation for injuries they claim were a direct result of another person’s negligence or intentional actions. 

Personal injury itself does not strictly mean physical harm – it can encompass the mental or emotional harm inflicted by another due to negligence or intent. 

Compensation that can be sought in a personal injury claim may include: 

  • Medical expenses 
  • Lost wages 
  • Pain and suffering (for physical and emotional distress) 
  • Punitive damages 

Key Differences Between Workers’ Compensation and Personal Injury 

While the workers’ compensation coverage and personal injury lines may be blurred when it comes to your work-related injury, there are some key differences between the two claims. 

No-Fault vs. Negligence 

One of the main elements of filing and building a case for a personal injury claim is negligence. To prove a personal injury claim, your workers’ comp attorney will need to present evidence that the negligent actions, or possible intent, of another party caused your injuries. 

A workers’ compensation claim, on the other hand, operates under a no-fault system. This means that even if a workplace injury was the direct result of your own actions, the protection and benefits would still be available to you. 

Access to Medical Treatment 

In a workers’ comp claim, much of your medical care and costs will lie fully with your employer and their workers’ comp coverage. They maintain full or near total control over the type of treatment you receive as an injured worker and bear the costs, from medical treatment to prescription medications. 

Filing a personal injury claim gives you a bit more control over your treatment, such as choosing a medical provider or which hospital to visit. But with more control comes the potential for more responsibility – you may have to pay out of pocket or rely on your own health insurance to pay for your care. 

While you may be able to receive compensation via a settlement, nothing is set in stone. 

Damages 

Workers’ comp and personal injury compensation benefits can overlap, but there are some additional benefits you may be able to receive depending on which claim you file. 

For example, pain and suffering damages are only available under a personal injury claim. Pain and suffering not only include the physical pain from the work-related injury but the mental and emotional pain and suffering as well. 

Statute of Limitations 

Time is of the essence when it comes to filing a claim and, as one of the leading personal injury law firms in Charleston, SC, we will always advise that gaining legal guidance and filing a claim is done as soon as possible after an accident. 

However, if you choose to wait, you are now on a deadline. Workers’ compensation claims must be filed within two years of your workplace injury, and you are required to notify your employer within 30 days of an accident. 

Personal injury claims, meanwhile, have a statute of limitations of three years. 

In both cases, we recommend seeking the help of our experienced workers’ comp lawyers conveniently near you immediately following an accident or injury. 

How Do I Know Which Claim to File? 

Most workplace injuries are eligible for workers’ compensation benefits but not necessarily for a personal injury claim. If you were performing workplace duties and suffered an injury from a workplace accident, you are eligible for workers’ compensation. 

However, if negligence was a factor in your accident, you may be entitled to file a personal injury claim as well. A successful outcome for one claim may affect your compensation in the other. 

Discuss your options with a workers’ compensation lawyer near you to help maximize compensation in your case and seek out which course of action is best for you. 

Don’t Get Overwhelmed with Confusion–Contact a Workers Compensation Attorney Today!

When it comes to distinguishing a workers’ compensation claim versus a personal injury claim, it can be overwhelming deciding which course of action is best for you and your recovery. 

At Hoffman Law Firm, our work-related injury attorneys near you are here to help! 

Located in both Georgetown and Charleston, SC, we support accident victims throughout the Palmetto State. We have established a reputation for success, as well as great service! 

To meet with a member of our team, schedule your free consultation today.

Share the Post:

Related Posts

Coastal Flooding & Road Safety: How King Tides Increase Your Car Accident Risk

One part of Lowcountry life most of us accept is the flooding. A rainstorm may make a trip downtown more difficult, and we know which roads might have water on them at high tide. When the annual King Tide hits, it can create even greater floodwaters – and even greater risks on the road. You might be asking yourself, “What actually is a King Tide?” Our team at Hoffman Law […]

Read More… from Coastal Flooding & Road Safety: How King Tides Increase Your Car Accident Risk

The Anatomy of a Personal Injury Settlement: Where Does the Money Actually Go?

You were injured. You sought out justice. You finally receive your personal injury settlement check, and the amount isn’t what you expected it to be. A common misconception in personal injury law is that the entire settlement amount goes straight into the injured party’s pocket, but it isn’t that simple. Navigating the outcome of your settlement is another complicated part of recovery, one that a skilled personal injury lawyer can […]

Read More… from The Anatomy of a Personal Injury Settlement: Where Does the Money Actually Go?